My Subjective Ranking Of The Best Brow Mascaras. Only The TOP Eyebrows Mascaras!

Ranking Of The Best Brow Mascaras

Hi there, darlings!

Today’s post is all about brow makeup and which brow makeup products work best, and how to give the brows a fabulous definition. Mascaras are some of the trendiest brow makeup products – a good brow mascara can help you achieve great results and thicker-looking brows! That’s why I decided to create a comparison of the most interesting eyebrow mascaras on the beauty market nowadays. Take a look at which products I rounded up! 

About my eyebrows

I have to admit that my eyebrows aren’t my strongest feature as they seriously lack some definition. I’ve always wanted to have eyebrows like Lily Collins or Dua Lipa… but unfortunately, nature has blessed me with sparse and thin eyebrows. It seems like they are barely there to be honest, especially in summer, when they look even fairer and you can barely say they’re there… That’s why I’m constantly looking for ideas on how to increase their volume. With a good brow mascara, I was able to get the best effect in the shortest time.

Eyebrow mascara – why do I recommend it?

Choosing a particular brow-styling product is an individual matter, everyone prefers something different and expects different makeup effects. However, you must know that if you expect an effect of full and voluminous brows, eyebrow mascara is the best choice. It can be used in many ways as it works great on its own or you can pair it with another brow makeup product, and it’s perfect for all types of eyebrows – whether they are thick or thin, unruly or sparse. What I love about it is that it makes the brows look thicker and neater, ensuring the brows are properly defined. Finally, a good brow mascara should be quick and easy to apply, and there’s really no way to overdo it or go wrong during the application. It’s a super easy hack for beautiful, thick, and define eyebrows. Of course, choosing a good product is key. That’s why I hope my ranking of the best brow mascaras will help you choose the right one for yourself. Hope you enjoy it!

Ranking of the best eyebrow mascaras. TOP brow mascaras

1. Nanobrow Shape Mascara

NANOBROW SHAPE MASCARA

I know that most rankings usually starts from the worst products and slowly moves on to the best ones, but luckily, this is not a radio top chart so I can freely reveal the ranking’s winner right away and describe this beauty gem I got my hands on thanks to a friend of mine who is a professional beautician. I know that most rankings usually starts from the worst products and slowly moves on to the best ones, but luckily, this is not a radio top chart so I can freely reveal the ranking’s winner right away and describe this beauty gem I got my hands on thanks to a friend of mine who is a professional beautician.

The Nanobrow brow mascara is truly unique and so far I have never come across such a cool mini brush with a pleasant formula and great precision during the application. The beautiful shades are sure to captivate you too, and its refined formula improves the texture and volume of your eyebrows. Dear readers, this eyebrow mascara is very precise, its formula is clump-free and doesn’t settle on the eyebrows in excess. Instead, it coats each brow hair beautifully and builds elegant volume while bringing out the beauty of my eyebrows incredibly! <3 In addition, the Nanobrow mascara is long-wear and comes at a great price! Make sure to check it out, because this is a real beauty bestseller!

2. YSL Couture Brow Mascara

YSL Couture Brow Mascara

The brow mascara from Yves Saint Laurent worked brilliant for me for a long time. First of all, what I can say about it is that it comes with a very convenient spoolie that reaches even tiny brow hairs. It works quite well and it’s long-wear, yet unfortunately, it is super expensive. The brow mascara from Yves Saint Laurent worked brilliant for me for a long time. First of all, what I can say about it is that it comes with a very convenient spoolie that reaches even tiny brow hairs. It works quite well and it’s long-wear, yet unfortunately, it is super expensive.

The formula with special fibers boosts volume while the semi-matte pigments add definition to the eyebrows. This brow mascara gives an interesting 3D effect, which of course I really enjoy. The only thing I don’t like is the price. That’s why I’m glad that thanks to the Nanobrow mascara, I can get the same sensational effect of fuller and defined eyebrows for a much cheaper price.

3. Dior Diorshow On Set Brow Mascara

DIORSHOW ON SET BROW

Another brow mascara in my ranking is an interesting choice by Dior. I like it mainly because it is made of 90% naturally derived ingredients and combined makeup with brow care. But that’s basically the end of its benefits because I find that the waterproof formula doesn’t quite work on the eyebrows – it makes this eyebrow mascara quite heavy and doesn’t allow it to create a very elegant effect. Another brow mascara in my ranking is an interesting choice by Dior. I like it mainly because it is made of 90% naturally derived ingredients and combined makeup with brow care. But that’s basically the end of its benefits because I find that the waterproof formula doesn’t quite work on the eyebrows – it makes this eyebrow mascara quite heavy and doesn’t allow it to create a very elegant effect.

It seems that it would work better for a big night out than for everyday wear. All because the formula is further enriched with microfibers that cling to brow hairs, adding volume and definition. This brow mascara also comes in quite lovely neutral shades. Unfortunately, this is not a cheap eyebrow mascara and is certainly not an option for anyone who does not like to overpay for their beauty products.

4. Benefit Gimme Brow Mascara

BENEFIT COSMETICS GIMME BROW+MINI

The ranking of the best and most recommended brow mascaras would not be complete without this mascara. I’ll be honest, I’ve read a lot about it on the net and it seems like you either love it or hate it, as Benefit cosmetics have it in common that they give a rather strong and often very bold makeup effects. The ranking of the best and most recommended brow mascaras would not be complete without this mascara. I’ll be honest, I’ve read a lot about it on the net and it seems like you either love it or hate it, as Benefit cosmetics have it in common that they give a rather strong and often very bold makeup effects.

The thick spoolie scoops up a large amount of the mascara making it possible to… hmmm… easily overdo your brow makeup. I was unsure of buying the full version of the mascara right away so I’m very glad that there’s also a tiny brow mascara to choose from. I’ll honestly admit that this mascara doesn’t look very impressive on my eyebrows or I maybe I don’t fully know how to use it properly. Immediately after the application, my brow hairs got that sticky finish I don’t like and I had to brush through them with a spoolie. And, of course, the whole brow makeup took forever. If you have had the opportunity to try this eyebrow mascara, please let me know whether it produced similar results in your case and what you think of it. From what I have noticed, many people feel very enthusiastic about it though.

5. Lancome Sourcils Styler Brow Mascara

Lancome Sourcils Styler Brow

I’m very fond of Lancome cosmetics so I had high hopes for their brow mascara as it looked very interesting: this unique teardrop-shaped spoolie really looked promising. And indeed, the mascara works lovely when it comes to shaping the brows properly and giving them a nice, neat, and sculpted look. I’m very fond of Lancome cosmetics so I had high hopes for their brow mascara as it looked very interesting: this unique teardrop-shaped spoolie really looked promising. And indeed, the mascara works lovely when it comes to shaping the brows properly and giving them a nice, neat, and sculpted look.

But unfortunately, this type of brush doesn’t do a good job of building volume or filling in gaps in the eyebrows. If I ever create a ranking of the best brow-styling gels, I might include this mascara there as it’s closer to a setting gel than a volumizing brow mascara. I was a little sad that I spent so much money on a product that works differently than I expected.

6. Kiko Milano Eyebrow Fibers Colored Mascara

Kiko Eyebrow Fibers Coloured Mascara

The ranking couldn’t miss a brow mascara from the Italian brand that is famous for its good quality makeup products. When it comes to brow makeup, the brand has created a brow mascara with special fibers that settle on brow hairs, building volume and helping to fill them in and give them the right shape. The ranking couldn’t miss a brow mascara from the Italian brand that is famous for its good quality makeup products. When it comes to brow makeup, the brand has created a brow mascara with special fibers that settle on brow hairs, building volume and helping to fill them in and give them the right shape.

The mascara does quite a good job in this regard but I think not everyone will like the slightly unnatural and glossy effect on the eyebrows. Also, I noticed that this eyebrow mascara changed its formula significantly after using it for over a month and I don’t know if it is just my case or if it is normal that after a few weeks, this mascara started to stick my brow hairs together a bit too much. What’s cool about it though is that it comes with a precise mini-brush, which can be used to ally the mascara on the eyebrows quite comfortably.

The best eyebrow mascara – ranking summary

Okay, dear readers! I think I have summed up and described all the most interesting brow mascaras that I got my hands on recently. To clarify, I’ll also add that I used a lot more different products of this type, but unfortunately, not all of them deserved to make it to the ranking in my view.  I think that the overall ratings and reviews of each of these products seem very interesting: it turns out that, of course, the iconic eyebrow mascaras from world-famous brands feature good quality and ensure good makeup effects but you don’t have to spend a lot of money to get a really good brow mascara. The wonderful Nanobrow Shape Mascara remains my undoubted favorite. I highly recommend this brow mascara to you. It ensures great quality for a really good price and it ensures lovely and long-wear makeup effects. What I really like about it is that I can add an extra coat of this mascara if feel like it to build up even more volume, for example, for a big night out.

Good eyebrow mascara – where to buy it?

You’re probably also wondering which store has your coveted eyebrow mascara on offer: Douglas, Sephora, or Walmart, or is it better to find some local beauty store that may have better special deals and more attractive prices? I think that in many boutiques and online beauty stores, prices sometimes change from month to month or even week to week, so it’s worth browsing the special offers. Remember that most beauty brands have their official online stores and you can easily find a product you want to try there.

And do you already have your favorite brow mascara? Which brow mascara do you recommend? Make sure to let me know in the comments whether you think any other brow mascara should be included in this ranking. Or maybe you also love Nanobrow Shape Mascara as much as I do?